I love Talia Hibbert! Her romances are so lovely and I love the little quirks that she gives every character. We stan MoroccItalian king Samir Bianchi!! I think this book handled the topic of domestic abuse incredibly well. Also, it was nice to see Ruth and Evan from A Girl Like Her!
I’m so sorry but I found the main characters incredibly immature and insufferable! I appreciated the Author’s note and I think the discussion of workplace harassment and gendered powered imbalance was incredibly important. BookTok…why’d y’all do me like this 🥲
If you’re a fan of the show Greenleaf, I would highly recommend this book. As a Black woman who grew up in the church (specifically with family members who were pastors of an A.M.E. Zion church) this book felt like coming home to me. The mothers of the church-their drama, adages, gossiping, compassion- were written in such an authentic way that I could hear their voices as they spoke. I could gush about this book all day. I love that the title is a nod to not just the mothers of the church but also the mothers of our three main characters in the novel. Each of their mothers has traumatized them in one way or another, and that trauma has brought them to they way each of them navigates their own life presently. I loved that the story was told from multiple points of view. Maybe it’s the theatre-lover in me but each time the “Mothers” narrated the story, I felt that they operated as a Greek chorus of sorts. If I had to make a complaint about this book, I would say that I wish the ending was a little more fleshed out without the major time jump but perhaps that’s for the best. Much like Nadia’s situation and relationships, some things will always be left unresolved .
I really wanted to love this book!! I had seen so many people gush about it on TikTok and YouTube. I felt like nothing happened in this story. I struggled to wrap my head around why Marianne was so unlikeable in high school. I feel like Rooney doesn’t delve into that, so I was left feeling like that was unbelievable. I thoroughly enjoyed any time Lorraine was present, specifically the portion where she rips Connell a new one for not taking Marianne to the Debs!!. I think I’ll try Conversations With Friends before I give up on this author!