This book was chaotic. Alex is literally the worst... even worse than Ben in November 9th... that's saying something. He lied to her for 8 years, stalked her, threatened her, killed people for her...actually insane. Ava is a moron for being with him idc how hot he is. This might be one of the worst books I've ever read. It would be a crime to rate this above a 1 star.