Scan barcode
A review by kris_mccracken
Storm Front by Jim Butcher
2.0
There's a certain allure to Harry Dresden, Chicago's only professional wizard-for-hire. With a trench coat, a battered VW Beetle, and a predilection for summoning storms to solve mysteries, he's a hardboiled private eye with a thaumaturgic twist. But while "Storm Front" casts a serviceable first spell in The Dresden Files series, it never quite manages to enchant.
My expectations were spoiled by the Rivers of London series, which offers richer worldbuilding and more inventive mashups of magic, crime, and science. By contrast, "Storm Front" feels like a curious patchwork: Raymond Chandler's noir sensibilities draped over medieval fantasy, with the occasional vintage horror flourish. Butcher is undeniably skilled at fusing genres, and the book has its moments of dark charm, but the end result leans more towards pastiche than innovation.
Dresden's knack for withholding crucial information "for their protection" grates after a while, creating artificial tension where genuine stakes would have been more satisfying. There's something self-indulgent about his internal monologues, too, verbose musings that slow the narrative's pace, like a magician distractedly rifling through props mid-performance.
The plot? Workmanlike, but rarely inspired. Dresden investigates a double homicide involving a magical heart-exploding spell while contending with shadowy figures from the underworld (both criminal and supernatural). It's all entertaining enough, but the twists are telegraphed, and the stakes feel perfunctory.
Where "Storm Front" falters most egregiously is in its treatment of gender. Dresden's self-declared chauvinism is presented as a quirk, but the narrative doubles down, reducing female characters to flimsy archetypes: temptress, damsel, femme fatale. Even when they appear powerful, their agency is often circumscribed by or contingent upon male intervention. This antiquated framing undermines the story's better qualities and leaves a sour aftertaste.
Ultimately, "Storm Front" is a decent enough opener to what's become a beloved series, but it lacks the alchemy to dazzle truly. It's entertaining in a Saturday-matinee way, but for those accustomed to more textured narratives, it falls short.
⭐ ⭐ 1/2
My expectations were spoiled by the Rivers of London series, which offers richer worldbuilding and more inventive mashups of magic, crime, and science. By contrast, "Storm Front" feels like a curious patchwork: Raymond Chandler's noir sensibilities draped over medieval fantasy, with the occasional vintage horror flourish. Butcher is undeniably skilled at fusing genres, and the book has its moments of dark charm, but the end result leans more towards pastiche than innovation.
Dresden's knack for withholding crucial information "for their protection" grates after a while, creating artificial tension where genuine stakes would have been more satisfying. There's something self-indulgent about his internal monologues, too, verbose musings that slow the narrative's pace, like a magician distractedly rifling through props mid-performance.
The plot? Workmanlike, but rarely inspired. Dresden investigates a double homicide involving a magical heart-exploding spell while contending with shadowy figures from the underworld (both criminal and supernatural). It's all entertaining enough, but the twists are telegraphed, and the stakes feel perfunctory.
Where "Storm Front" falters most egregiously is in its treatment of gender. Dresden's self-declared chauvinism is presented as a quirk, but the narrative doubles down, reducing female characters to flimsy archetypes: temptress, damsel, femme fatale. Even when they appear powerful, their agency is often circumscribed by or contingent upon male intervention. This antiquated framing undermines the story's better qualities and leaves a sour aftertaste.
Ultimately, "Storm Front" is a decent enough opener to what's become a beloved series, but it lacks the alchemy to dazzle truly. It's entertaining in a Saturday-matinee way, but for those accustomed to more textured narratives, it falls short.
⭐ ⭐ 1/2