Scan barcode
A review by benwillie
The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger
3.0
Hmm...
This is either one of the most inane or one of the most meaningful books I've ever read and the fact that I don't know which concerns me. Is this just the stream-of-consciousness story about a boy "disillusioned" about society and whose constant flitting whimsy devalues his confident declarations (which are rarely executed)—or is this a profound commentary about the prideful state of fallen man? Having such a fickle narrator makes for an unusual story. I feel as if the author must be making some abstruse point about the fakeness imposed on us by "societal constructs," but I don't think that a young capricious boy was the best avenue to convey that message. It is supposedly a great classic, but I'd have to think about it a lot more to understand what, if anything, this book advocates through such a child-like perspective.
Also, a star off for all the incessant swearing which makes me unwilling to recommend this.
This is either one of the most inane or one of the most meaningful books I've ever read and the fact that I don't know which concerns me. Is this just the stream-of-consciousness story about a boy "disillusioned" about society and whose constant flitting whimsy devalues his confident declarations (which are rarely executed)—or is this a profound commentary about the prideful state of fallen man? Having such a fickle narrator makes for an unusual story. I feel as if the author must be making some abstruse point about the fakeness imposed on us by "societal constructs," but I don't think that a young capricious boy was the best avenue to convey that message. It is supposedly a great classic, but I'd have to think about it a lot more to understand what, if anything, this book advocates through such a child-like perspective.
Also, a star off for all the incessant swearing which makes me unwilling to recommend this.