3.5

I liked this one better than most, which was REALLY surprising after I realized one of the main characters was a minister. I've been soured to religion and was expecting to hate this book, but it wasn't the case. In fact, if there was a church with Noah as the minister, I might actually consider going. And I adored Ellie. Strong, hardworking, eternally optimistic no matter what was thrown at her, yet realistic about people and their perceptions. She's was a joy to meet.

The Paul and Vanni storyline was hard and sad, but it was a good addition to the book.