3.5 stars. There's just something about NYC during the holidays that I just love in romances... Seth was sweet and adorable and the definition of a green flag. I liked that Abby confronted and worked through her trauma and I would say that a good portion of this revolved around that. I liked having a holiday romance that was about Hanukkah and learning about that more. There were moments when the romance felt like the side and just kind of there and for that reason, I had to rate it lower because I expected more sugary sweet romance.