Ok so I’m going to start with a huge critique. If you are going to write a book about music, maybe do research into the music you feature in order to make sure you are being accurate. There is a song mentioned that they say Hunter Hayes sings when in truth it is WALKER Hayes. Like was there an editor? All in all if you want a quick little Christmas rom-com that is completely unserious despite the occasional mention of grief this is your story. Nick and Noel are great characters and even the minor characters are very fun to read. However this reads like a knock off version of some of your favorites. A good “reading goal” read, but you could also skip.