I loved this book, it's easy autumnal romcom fun and was exactly the vibe I needed at the time I needed it - that makes it a five star read for me. It's got the bickering main couple (big fan), magic that easily fits into an otherwise modern world (as someone whose favourite series is Charmed, this is also a big win), a cute small town setting (as a Gilmore Girls lover this hits the sweet spot), with incredible supporting characters - Gwyn, you're the best I love you. 

It gave me autumn feels in early March, and wrapped my heart in a gentle hug with its tea-and-pumpkin-patch atmosphere. I love these messy (and often stupid) characters with my whole heart, thoroughly enjoyed the magical hijinks, and thought it well balanced between action and emotional reflection.