I really loved Brown Girls. It’s the story of second-generation immigrant girls growing up in Queens. The book follows them from early childhood through to the end of life, but the emphasis is heavily on their teens and twenties, the key coming-of-age years. What immediately stands out is that this novel is told in the first person plural, “we”. This does mean the reader never gets to know any of the girls individually, but I found it really drew me into the story as a reader, making me feel as if I was one of the group, or at the very least a fly on the wall as a group of girlfriends got together. The collective voice vividly highlighted the universality of some of their experiences like sexism, racism, and balancing the expectations of immigrant parents with the realities of life in America. Yet the diversity and individuality of their different experiences came through clearly as well. Some girls were encouraged by teachers; others were put down. Some went to college and achieved professional success; others did not. Some became parents; other aborted unwanted pregnancies, struggled with fertility, or chose to remain childless. Some escaped Queens; others remained there their whole life. The writing was lyrical, while still feeling rooted in reality. I’ve never been to Queens but this depiction feels vividly authentic. It’s easy to believe I’ve been transported there and given the opportunity to share the lives of this group of Brown girls. A unique book that is sure to stick with me. 

Brown Girls is transportive, beautiful, enjoyable, a musical and fast-paced read. It's all feeling and rhythm. As a brown girl, as a Pilipina with immigrant parents, even though my context was/is in some ways very different, there were so many moments where my heart sang and ached (sometimes my heart sang to Aaliyah and Mariah. :)). I felt seen in a way I don't often get in novels, even as the book spoke to so many different kinds of brown girls, brown lives.

I think its form and concept is a true feat. That balance of the collective "we" voice with just enough specificity to still be real and personal rather than theoretical; the ooze of place and senses and emotion in a wide swath; the rhythm, the deft control of how the reader runs alongside pace then slows down, or turns focus one way, then the other... 

I found some of the prose itself to be cliché, and some moments to feel a bit forced,

including the inclusion of COVID-19 as another reviewer mentioned and the last chapter in general,

which is why I didn't give this a higher rating myself.

I read this in about two days! If you're the type, I think it would be a great one to read in one sitting and just let wash over you.

I received an advance copy from the publisher Random House via Netgalley for review purposes. This in no way influences my review; all words, thoughts, and opinions are my own.

Brown Girls is a fascinating, think-y story. It isn’t wholly clear who the main character(s) are and is told entirely with the pronoun tense of “we.” This is a super interesting, compelling read that I found difficult to put down. And the writing style flows beautifully, adding to the emotional impact. It is a story of growing up as a brown girl in Queens, NY, a story of friendships, and a story of family. Of figuring out your place in the world and finding connections to roots and community. It was a little shocking when Trump’s presidency and the Covid pandemic became a part of the book, but I think it added to the realism of the story and the experiences it was representing.