Reviews

Not Dead Yet: The Memoir by Phil Collins

thewordofjeff's review

Go to review page

4.0

Thoroughly enjoyed the story of Phil Collins' life thus far. While extremely talented in the musical arts he was less so in the area of romantic relationships, something he admits with regret and honesty. That's something a lot of us can probably identify with. He takes you through all the highs and the lows of his life and the near-death experience that would seem to have given him a new lease on life at the age of 65.

Something I did that made this a unique reading was that I did not confine myself to reading. It occurred to me that I had most of his songs in my iTunes library or could listen to them on YouTube, so whenever he mentioned a song title I would stop and pull it up to listen and enjoy. It made the reading take a bit longer, but it was fun to do and added to the story, for me.

cheskacolombo's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This one took a while to get through - as with a lot of other musician's memoirs, it was a little all over the place and lacked a clear linear narrative. BUT - as with any good memoir, it was a really in depth look into Phil's life, journey and career and I appreciate that it included all the gritty details, even if they weren't particularly flattering or heroic. The behind the scenes stories about other musicians and various household names were the best. The chapter that focuses on Phil's exclusion from the live Beatles performance video as well as the saga that went with his percussion work for George Harrison is a story I've already told so many times to fellow music lovers, even though I'm far from a huge Beatles fan. Even the tales of projects that never came to fruition, like those with Adele and Danny Devito, were really interesting tidbits that make me feel like I could SLAY some Phil Collins trivia if I had to.

Overall, despite its structure, I enjoy the on/off year or so I spent with this memoir and it makes me appreciate all that Phil is still doing musically even more.

susancdavenport's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I read it over two days and was entertained all the way through. I love books written by musicians, et al, because I am always intrigued by the artist’s history and the inspirations behind some of my favorite songs. If you are a Phil Collins and/or 80’s music fan, I think you’ll be entertained.

cathydeg's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I remember being introduced to Genesis when I was…13? Fell in love with Trick of the Tail, and loved every album the band put out. Got to see them in concert, albeit from far right field at Philly’s Veteran’s Stadium.
Never knew of this book until it was mentioned in an article on their reunion tour.
Phil Collins certainly led quite the life, and he’s very candid about both the highs and lows. I felt the joy and the sadness, success and disappointment. I never knew what the next page might bring; I was along for his ride. And the music! Good memories!
Phil Collins…a complex man, a complex story.

bigdog356c's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Not many people could go through relationship, children, alcoholism, heath issues and still be one of the biggest rock and roll stars of the 80's and 90's. A truthful telling of a sobering tale

thomas_edmund's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I always get a bit confused reviewing biographies - what exactly am I reviewing - the quality of the book, or the quality of the person. I've seen many negative reviews about famous folk more because people do not like what the stories reveal versus whether its a good book or not.

So I'm going to try and cover both.

First of all the style of this book is a relatively factual, dry-ish but revealing summary of Collins' life. It's a fairly fast paced summary of Collins' early years, musical career and personal life. While some early moments were frankly a little boring, its hard not to get a little caught up in the various debacles within this book and for the most part it was hard to put down this book as it was well structured and timeframed.

What struck me a little is it felt very 'at arms length' more on this later but I had sense that often events were glossed over, sometimes with a dose of humour, sometimes more in the mad rush which appeared to be Collins' work schedule.

I felt that a big fan of Genesis and Collins would probably get a lot out of this book if they already felt very familiar with the music and evens of each era - as somewhere aware of, but not really knowing much about the man at first it was still a good read, but sometimes it felt very much like the information that Collin wanted to present about himself rather than true insight.

So as to the life of Phil Collins I was actually quite shocked. I guess I had (perhaps like many) thought of Collins as a kind of kindly uncle of music. The first red flag was mention of 3 marriages - but I figured that many famous musicians make for poor husbands for various reasons so didn't frown too much.

However as the story progresses Collins revealed that he punched a wall and true a can of small change across the room during a breakup with his 1st wife, he also wholesale moved countries to stalk her after the breakup (in his words he thought we was going to win her back which is a common perspective of abusers stalking their exes). I wasn't too surprised to find that after a brief Google his first wife's account is that Collins was angry and unhinged and unfair balancing his musical career with his family.

The red flags continued to fly as Collins continues to cheat his way through a 2nd marriage, eventually pursuing a woman half his age who at the time of writing is divorcing him for the second time. He disturbingly reconciled with her after an illness or accident left her paralyzed (attracted to vulnerability much)

Collins drug and alcohol concerns also fit this pattern, erupted or emerging once his career ended due to physical ailments.

Now obviously Collins is hardly the most toxic musician in the world, and perhaps in some respects might seem tame in comparison, but what struck me is the way that Collins describes everything as a sort of whiny victim who can't understand why endlessly working and neglecting his families is resulting in divorce, the way he has been able to tell his story - often to the hurt of his exes is all deeply problematic. Again plenty of musos have strings of problematic behaviour but its usually more a sense of immature egotism - whereas Collins gives the impression of having a black hole inside himself that when music stopped filling it he turned to drinking and pills. While he puts a lot of effort to present himself as sympathetic his story is filled with justifications, minimizations and as mentioned a strange arms length from empathy.

So in summary Not Dead Yet is a very strange read - probably not what many might expect, but at the very least a highly interesting look at Collins life.

samanthasweets's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

One of those “never meet your heroes” things, I fear.

tspelczechquer's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

PC's memoir, part of his resurgence through a re-release of his solo albums and a possible tour, is occasionally brutal in its honesty, often terribly funny, and always written in a voice that can only be his.

larleej's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional informative reflective

3.0

bealittlebrave's review against another edition

Go to review page

funny reflective sad medium-paced

4.25